Members of sub-project can't be add as subscribers of task in main project by Project members


#1

Observed Behavior:
Members added to sub-project can’t view subscribed tasks (by tag MainProject in subscribers) in Main project.

Expected Behavior:
Members of subrojects to be able to view tasks in Main projects with set subscribers to All project members.

Phabricator Version:

phabricator 3f2419eebb6114cd8b85d8763289efdb8c427125 (Sat, Feb 24) (branched from 4c7370a1a3b0b59f4ce6fc731a59b637f75c0ed2 on origin) arcanist 8fe1d7701e5daa3b7c8d96847fa335c0fbf66816 (Sat, Feb 17) (branched from be1dd7e2ba230d77f894637fdcbc7d5a47dc7082 on origin) phutil 03e5605b42e4e5ee721a282408f9dfc75179f671 (Sat, Feb 24) (branched from a0de1601cb60f79c805582bdc5be03ac7058fb41 on origin)

Reproduction Steps:
If we have

  • Main project;
  • two Sub projects;
  • task in Main project with subscribers All project members (by tag Main project);
  • add new member/s to Sub project1 OR Sub project2
    New member/s are listed in Main project members.
    Can’t see any task in Main project even subscribed by All project members.
    If added manually exmpl “All project members + User1 + User2” (user1 and user2 are members of sub projects) it’s OK.

#2

Anyone ? Or no one uses sub-projects ?


#3

That isn’t problem for anyone? I’m more than surprised !


#4

ok, I was able to reproduce. Missing reproduction step is "Set View Policy to “Subscribers”.

Upstreamed as https://secure.phabricator.com/T13104.


#5

Yes correct adding but it stands to reason:

  • task in Main project with subscribers All project members (by tag Main project);